Good Faith Test – Rochester Bankruptcy and Debt Relief

Determining Chapter 13 Repayment Plan Payment

If debtor does not qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, that debtor is likely to qualify for Chapter 13 bankruptcy. The most important issue for anyone filing Chapter 13 is to know is how much their Chapter 13 Plan payment will be. In my opinion, given the typical 5 year duration of Chapter 13, properly set plan payment is the most important factor in whether the case will be a success.

Determining the amount of the payment can be challenging at the very beginning of the case. Early estimates of plan payment can change significantly as more information becomes available.

Generally, there are four tests applicable to determining the amount of the Chapter 13 Plan payment:

The Chapter 13 Means Test (officially, the “Chapter 13 Statement of Your Current Monthly Income and Calculation of Commitment Period and Calculation of Your Disposable Income”);
The Disposable Income Test;
The Chapter 7 Liquidation Analysis Test; and
The Required Payments Test

The Chapter 13 Means Test was imposed when BAPCPA became law in 2005. The Means Test’s purpose is to determine whether debtor’s Plan would be 3 years or 5 years long, and to have an objective way to determine the amount of the payment. This calculation uses one of the established four methods of determining your Chapter 13 Plan payment.

The Disposable Income Test is the only one of the four tests that is strictly based on debtor’s ability to pay. Initially, debtor’s net household income is calculated and from that figure, debtor’s actual reasonable monthly expenses are subtracted. The resulting number–disposable income–is Chapter 13 Plan payment. That calculation does not include a deduction for the debts that will be paid through the Chapter 13 case, such as mortgage arrears, car loan payments, student loan payments, tax payments, and credit card bills.

In the Chapter 7 Liquidation Analysis Test, bankruptcy attorney looks at how much debtor’s general unsecured creditors (typically credit cards, medical bills and personal loans) would receive in a hypothetical Chapter 7 case. In many cases, they would receive zero, because there are no non-exempt assets with equity, and creditors would get nothing in a Chapter 7 case. The total amount of payments under Chapter 13 plan can’t be less than the amount determined under the Liquidation Analysis Test.

The last test is the Required Payments Test. Usually, priority debt, such as recent taxes and domestic support obligations, must be paid in full during the course of the Chapter 13 case. Mortgage and other secured debt arrears must also be paid in full, along with unpaid attorney fees, trustee commissions and (in most cases) at least a nominal amount to the general unsecured creditors. Add these payments up, and you reach the Required Payments.

After all of the numbers under each test have been calculated, debtor is required pick the highest amount, which becomes the plan payment. At the same time, that figure may change during the case as creditors submit their proofs of claim, as debtor’s income, expenses and assets change. This figure may also change depending on trustee’s view of the debtor’s financial circumstances.

If you contemplating filing Chapter 7 Bankruptcy or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy, or are dealing with debt problems in Western New York, including Rochester, Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Henrietta, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation with a Rochester, NY, bankruptcy lawyer.

Treatment of Social Security Benefits in Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

I have previously written that Social Security income, whether retirement, survivor benefits, SSI or Social Security disability are not included in debtor’s income for the purposes of means testing. While not included in the means test figures, do the debtors have to include such payments in their Chapter 13 Bankruptcy plan and use that income toward making their plan payments?

According to a decision from the Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of New York, a Chapter 13 Plan can be confirmed despite not including Social Security retirement income. In In Re Burnett, together with its companion case, In re Uzailkos, the proposed payment plans did not include social security income on Schedule I. As filed, the Burnett plan projected paying usecured creditors 10% of their claims, Uzailko’s plan proposed to pay creditors 37%.

Because social security income was not included, the Burnett’s Schedule I income exceeded Schedule J expenses by $493,67. If social security was included, the income available for repayment would increase by $878 to $1,371.67. For Uzailko, the available payment amount would increase $400.25 to $1,496.25.

The Chapter 13 Trustee filed objections to both plans arguing that the cases were not filed in “good faith” because social security income was not included in calculating the minimum plan payment. A “good faith” objection is the general objection to confirmation of a Chapter 13 Plan. Under the Bankruptcy Code Section 1325(a)(3), a plan which fails to pay this disposable income minimum can be denied confirmation on the grounds the debtor’s plan was not filed in good faith.

Social security income different from other forms of income under BAPCPA. Under BAPCPA, Section 101(10A) was modified to exclude Social Security benefits from the the Chapter 7 Bankruptcy means test and the Chapter 13 Bankruptcy disposable income test.

After reviewing different lines of cases addressing these issues, the court accepted the reasoning in a series of cases that held that the treatment of social security income in BAPCPA’s disposable income test precluded requiring a chapter 13 debtor to apply social security income in a plan. Accordingly, as there were no other ‘bad faith’ factors in Burnett and Uzalko cases, the judge confirmed the plans over the trustee’s objections.

If you contemplating filing Chapter 7 Bankruptcy or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy, or are dealing with debt problems in Western New York, including Rochester, Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation with a Rochester, NY, bankruptcy lawyer.

Chapter 7 Means Test

Under the current version of the bankruptcy law, in order to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the debtor must pass a “means test” which will determine whether debtor, or his family, is eligible to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

The purpose of the means test is to keep debtors from abusing the bankruptcy system by filing when they don’t have to do so. The presumption is that if the debtor fails the means test, he/she is trying to abuse the system.

If the debtor’s income is below the median income for families in New York, based on Census Bureau statistics, the debtor will be eligible for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. The current means test figures for New York are listed here.

The means test uses the income of the debtor for the six months leading up to the filing of the bankruptcy. The monthly income figure for that time is referred to as the debtor’s “current monthly income”.

Even if the debtor’s income has recently decreased, the use of the six months before the filing date may make the debtor’s income for bankruptcy purposes higher than it will actually be and place him/her into an income situation where he/she may be required to file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

If you make more than the median income for families in New York, your income over the past six months is considered, along with mortgage and car payments, back taxes and child support obligations, and school expenses up to $1,500 per year. You won’t be eligible for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy if, after deducting these amounts, and the living expenses provided in the Internal Revenue Service’s national collection standards, you have a monthly disposable income of more than $100.00 per month.

If your monthly disposable income is more than $166.66, you have failed the means test, and cannot qualify for Chapter 7.

If your monthly disposable income is between $100.00 and $166.66, and that is enough to pay more than 25% of your unsecured, nonpriority debts (credit card bills, student loans, medical bills, and so on) over a five-year period, then you fail the means test, and Chapter 7 won’t be available to you. If it is not enough to pay more than 25% of your unsecured, nonpriority debts over a five-year period, then you pass the means test, and Chapter 7 remains an option.

If you don’t qualify for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, your only option would be a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

If you are dealing with debt problems in Rochester, New York; Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation.

Bankruptcy Basics – The Process of Filing and Completing Chapter 13 Bankruptcy

Chapter 13 has helped many to resolve their debts and save their homes from foreclosure. The following is a short description of a typical process that someone filing Chapter 13 bankruptcy goes through, from the initial meeting and until a discharge is received.

The initial stage of a Chapter 13 bankruptcy usually involves meeting with your bankruptcy attorney and discussing the case. The attorney will typically ask you to prepare a bankruptcy questionnaire, in which you will be asked to list your income and expenses, assets and liabilities, and describe your financial dealings over the past few years. Once the questionnaire is completed, your bankruptcy lawyer will be able to review and identify various exemptions applicable to your assets, determine whether certain of your debts are dischargeable or not, and will try to do bankruptcy planning to preserve as many of your assets as possible.

Your next step will be taking the credit counseling course. Under the bankruptcy law, you must complete the course before your bankruptcy petition can be filed with the bankruptcy court. The course must be taken from an authorized provider and can be done in person, over the telephone or internet. You will also have to provide your bankruptcy attorney with copies of your pay stubs for 60 days preceding the filing, and a copy of your most recent tax return.

Once the above steps are completed, your petition will be prepared and filed with the bankruptcy court. Concurrently with the petition, a copy of your credit counseling certificate and copies of your paystubs will be filed. Once the bankruptcy petition is filed, the automatic stay begins and protects you from all collection activities by your creditors. The automatic stay will last until the end of your bankruptcy case, unless it is lifted by the bankruptcy court. Your petition will include a repayment plan pursuant to which your disposable income will be used to repay creditors.

Within 45 days of your filing, a meeting of the creditors, also known as 341 hearing, will take place. You will have to come to the bankruptcy court in Rochester, if you reside in Monroe County, and answer the questions posed to you by the bankruptcy trustee. The trustee will typically ask you questions about your financial affairs, your income, expenses, assets and liabilities. You also may have to answer questions from your creditors who have the right to appear at the hearing. You will have to swear under oath that the information you provided in your petition is complete and accurate. After the hearing the trustee will issue a report to the bankruptcy court stating whether he recommends that your repayment plan be confirmed.

A typical Chapter 13 plan involves using your disposable income to repay all or a portion of your debts to the creditors over the next three to five years. The plan provides a repayment schedule that you’ll comply with to catch up on your past-due balances while staying current with other payments. Filing of a Chapter 13 bankruptcy can stop foreclosure and allow you to repay any mortgage arrears over the duration of your plan. Your plan can include such debts as mortgage and other secured and unsecured loan arrears and any other debts. You must make your first payment (as part of the repayment plan) within 30 days of filing your petition. If such payment is not made, the court may dismiss your case.

Within 45 days after the meeting of the creditors, you will have to complete the financial management course. If you will not complete it, you will not become eligible for discharge. The course is designed to help you make the most of your bankruptcy and includes tips on saving, managing money and handling credit.

Within 30 days after the 341 hearing, your confirmation hearing will be scheduled. On that date, you will appear with your attorney before Hon. John C. Ninfo, United States Bankruptcy Judge for the Western District of New York, who will make the ultimate decision whether to approve your Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

Once the plan has been approved, the trustee will typically enter a wage deduction order pursuant to which, all or a portion of your plan payments will be taken out of your wages and paid directly to the bankruptcy trustee. The trustee, in turn, will be making the payments to your creditors. You are required to make your final payment under the plan within five years of filing your petition. After doing so, you will receive your bankruptcy discharge and officially be out of Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

You will not be eligible for Chapter 13 bankruptcy protection if you had filed for bankruptcy in the past four years, so make sure you tell your bankruptcy lawyer whether you had past bankruptcy filings.

If you are dealing with debt problems in Rochester, New York, Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation.

Chapter 7, Chapter 13 and Means Test in Bankruptcy

The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (“BAPCPA”) included significant changes to the prior bankruptcy law, specifically, a financial test which allowed bankruptcy courts to determine who could qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and who could not. This test is commonly called the “Means Test.” If you fail the Means Test, you may still file for bankruptcy protection, however, you would be limited to filing under Chapter 13 of the Bankruptcy Code, and would have to repay all or a portion of your debt over time.

The Means Test is a two-part test that compares your income and expenses.

The first part of the Means Test compares your current monthly income to the median monthly income in your state for a family the size as yours. For the cases filed after March 15, 2009, this table is found here. If your income is less than the median income, you qualify for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, and do not need to complete the second part of the Means Test. For New York State, the median income numbers are:

One Earner Two People Three People Four People*

$46,523 $57,006 $67,991 $83,036

* Add $6,900 for every individual in excess of four.

If your income is higher than the median income, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you can’t file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, but it requires you to proceed to the second step in the test which is more complex.

The second part of the Means Test contains two-parts. First, you subtract your allowed monthly living expenses (determined by IRS guidelines) from your monthly income to come up with your monthly “disposable income.” If your projected disposable income over the next five years totals less than $6,000 ($100/month), you pass the Means Test and can file under Chapter 7.

If your projected disposable income over the next five years is greater than $10,000, you fail the Means Test and will not be allowed to file Chapter 7.

If your projected disposable income is between $6,000 and $10,000, yet another calculation is required. This calculation compares your disposable income over the next five years to a percentage of your unsecured debt to determine whether any significant repayment to your creditors is possible. If your disposable income over that five years is greater than 25% of your unsecured, non-priority debts, you fail the Means Test and cannot file under Chapter 7. If your disposable income over a five year period is less than 25% of your unsecured, non-priority debts, you pass the Means Test and can filed Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

If you qualify under the Means Test, it does not require you to file under Chapter 7. There may additional reasons why you should not file under Chapter 7, and instead choose to file under Chapter 13. Any decision to file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy should be made only after considering alternatives and consulting with a knowledgeable bankruptcy lawyer.

If you don’t pass the Means Test, you may still file bankruptcy but are limited to using Chapter 13 bankruptcy which is a 3 to 5 year debt repayment plan. In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, your payment plan is based upon what you can afford to pay your creditors, not on what your creditors want you to pay.

The above is a short summary of the Means Test. There are other factors that may have an effect on the Means Test.

New York Bankruptcy Exemptions

If you are filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy in New York, your property becomes a part of bankruptcy estate, which will be administered by the bankruptcy court. In Chapter 7, certain property is exempt and you can keep it. Federal bankruptcy exemptions are not available in the State of New York.

Under New York law, you can exempt or protect certain property from creditors when you file bankruptcy. After filing for bankruptcy, this property is safe. There are some limits on certain exemptions such as equity that you have in a home or in a vehicle. The difference between the cost of the item and the amount owed on the item is the definition of equity. If the item, such as home or vehicle, secured by a loan and payments made on time, the equity is protected by your exemptions. A debtor must generally pay the trustee the value of the non-exempt property to keep the property. If you choose to keep the property, continual timely payments ensure protection of the property through bankruptcy.

The following lists most important New York exemptions applicable in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy cases:

Homestead

Real property, including mobile home, condominium, or co-op, up to $50,000 per filer.

Personal Property

Clothing, furniture, refrigerator, TV, radio, sewing machine, security deposits with landlord or utility company, tableware, cooking utensils and crockery, stoves with fuel to last 60 days, health aids (including service animals with food), church pew or seat, wedding ring, bible, schoolbooks, pictures; books up to $50; domestic animals with food to last 60 days and up to $450; watch to $35; spendthrift trust fund principal; 90% of trust fund income if not created by debtor; college tuition savings program trust fund; recovery for injury to exempt property up to 1 year after receiving. Exemptions cannot exceed a total of $5,000 including tools of trade and limited annuity.

Burial plot up to 1/4 acre without a structure on it.

Savings and loan savings up to $600.

Motor vehicle up to $2,400; lost future earnings recoveries needed for support; personal injury recoveries up to 1 year after receipt; wrongful death recoveries for a person you depended upon for support.

IN LIEU OF Homestead exemption, the lesser of the following: up to $2,500 cash or up to $5,000 after exemptions for personal property taken

Wages

90% of earned but unpaid wages received within 60 days of filing for bankruptcy; 90% of earnings from milk sales to milk dealers; 100% for a noncommissioned private, officer or musician in the U.S. or N.Y. state armed forces.

Pensions

Tax exempt retirement accounts; Traditional and Roth IRAs up to $1,095,000 per person.

ERISA-qualified plans, Keoghs and IRAs needed for support.

Public Benefits

Unemployment benefits; veterans’ benefits; Social Security; aid to blind, aged, and disabled; crime victims’ compensation; home relief, local public assistance; public assistance; worker’s compensation.

Tools of Trade

Professional furniture, books, instruments, farm machinery, team and food for 60 days, up to $600 total; arms, swords, uniforms, equipment, horse, emblem and medal of a military member.

Alimony and Child Support

Alimony and child support.

Insurance

Annuity contract benefits due to the debtor if he or she paid for the contract up to $5,000, if purchased within 6 months of filing for bankruptcy and not tax-deferred.

Life insurance proceeds left at death if policy prohibits use to pay creditors.

Disability or illness benefits up to $400 per month; life insurance proceeds, dividends, interest, loan, cash, or surrender value if beneficiary is not the debtor or if the debtor’s spouse has taken out the policy.

Miscellaneous

Business partnership property.

To keep non-exempt property, a debtor must generally pay the trustee the value of the non-exempt property.

The exemptions are also relevant if you are filing a Chapter 13 bankruptcy since your bankruptcy has to pass the “good faith” test. The good faith test involves making sure that unsecured creditors will be paid at least as much under Chapter 13 bankruptcy, as if a Chapter 7 bankruptcy had been filed. Generally, this involves valuing of all the nonexempt property the debtor owns.