Procedure – Page 9 – Rochester Bankruptcy and Debt Relief

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy and Tax Refunds

If you file a bankruptcy case between January and April, you may be expecting a tax refund. Your Chapter 7 bankruptcy trustee may try to take your tax refund from you. Tax refunds are probably the largest single type of asset which debtors lose in bankruptcy. In New York, the tax refund may protected by your cash exemption up to $2,500, if you are not claiming a homestead exemption.

If only one spouse is filing for bankruptcy, and they file a joint tax return, Rochester Chapter 7 trustees usually take position that one half of the refund belongs to the trustee, subject to the applicable exemption.

In addition, here in Rochester, some of the Chapter 7 trustees frequently ask for a copy of the debtor’s income tax return for the year the bankruptcy is filed in. This request may make place early in the year, even though the tax return would not be filed several months later. The trustees’ goal is to see whether or not a portion of the income tax refund can be pro rated from the beginning of the year to the date of filing bankruptcy. If this prorated portion of the income tax refund is large enough, the trustee may make a demand that a portion fo the refund be turned over to the trustee.

One way of dealing with these issues is to wait to file your bankruptcy until after the tax refund was spent on family necessities. It is important to disclose the tax refund to your lawyer and the trustee, since a bankruptcy trustee can simply write to the Internal Revenue Service and have it send the tax refund directly to the trustee, and a deliberate failure to disclose information can be a basis for a denial of discharge.

If you are dealing with debt problems in Western New York, including Rochester, Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation with a bankruptcy attorney.

Chapter 13 Bankruptcy and Property Tax Arrears

Because most mortgages contain real estate tax escrow provisions, there are not as many Chapter 13 debtors who have unpaid real estate taxes due when they file their Chapter 13 plans as there are debtors who have mortgage arrearages. However, Chapter 13 debtors frequently do have significant unpaid real estate taxes due on their residences, and in many cases, the need to pay these unpaid real estate taxes over time in order to save their homes is one of the primary purposes of the Chapter 13 filing.

If you are filing Chapter 13 bankruptcy, and you have real property tax arrears, a typical plan will provide for a payment of such arrears in full over the life of the plan. Local municipalities, to whom such taxes are owed, will be treated as secured creditors under the plan and will receive full payment of taxes owed. In addition, any such municipality will be entitled to interest on the money owed.

Here in Rochester, local municipalities usually receive 18% interest rate on the real property tax arrears. Once the bankruptcy is filed, any such arrears will be subject to the New York State judgment interest rate of 9%. Judge Ninfo has previously addressed this issue in In re Clark, holding that the statutory rate is an appropriate post-confirmation interest rate under Section 1325(a)(5)(B)(ii) to be paid.

In view of the above, a bankruptcy lawyer must make sure that the proposed plan allows for full repayment of property tax arrears, together with appropriate interest, and that the debtor is able to afford payments under the plan.

Chapter 7 and Right of Redemption

A “redemption” is provided for under Section 722 of the Bankruptcy Code and is available for Chapter 7 debtors. That provision allows an individual debtor to retain personal property when that property has been used to secure a debt. The debtor must pay the fair market value of the item to the creditor. That fair market value determines to what extent the creditor is secured. The second choice is to pay the amount of the secured creditor’s debt. The third choice is to sign a reaffirmation agreement and continue to be legally obligated on the debt again. The last choice is to surrender the item to the secured creditor. Under Section 722, a debtor may be able to get the lien released for far less than what he owes. So, for example, if you owe a creditor $10,000 on a car and the fair market value of the car is $5,000, the Bankruptcy Code allows you to pay you $5,000 to redeem the car. That amount must be paid in one lump sum to that creditor. If the creditor agrees with the value, then either the debtor or the creditor has to submit a stipulated order of redemption. If the creditor does not agree with the value, then the debtor has to file a motion for redemption, and a hearing will be set with the judge deciding what the value of the item is. There are deadlines involved in the redemption process. The debtor has to have the money to redeem the item and be able to pay the creditor, with many debtors turning to family members and friends. There are also financial institutions that offer financing in such situations.

Redemption should be considered as an option in Chapter 7, if you own a vehicle that is worth thousands of dollars less than the debt on the vehicle – in other words, you are upside down on the vehicle. It should also be considered if the debtor is behind on payments or has a spotty payment history. In Western New York, Judge Ninfo has ruled that the standard for determining the value of a motor vehicle to be redeemed under Section 722 is its wholesale value. See In re Barse. You and your lawyer should carefully examine redemption as option if there is a significant disparity between the amount owed and the property’s fair market value.

Removing Judgments After the Bankruptcy

If a creditor obtains a judgment against a debtor, that judgment, if filed, becomes a lien against any real property owned by the debtor. Any such judgment lien against real property can be removed from the property, if the lien impairs an exemption you claim in your bankruptcy. In New York State, you can only remove a judgment lien against your personal residence. Debtor’s bankruptcy attorney usually files a motion pursuant to section 522(f) of the Bankruptcy Code. A typical motion includes a number of attachments such as a copy of the deed, mortgage, current mortgage statement, a recent appraisal of the property, and copies of the judgment filed in the local County Clerk’s office.

Typically, the debtor is faced with the following situation. The debtor owns a home with the total equity of less that New York’s homestead exemption, which is currently $50,000 for a single debtor and $100,000 for a married couple filing jointly. What a $50,000 homestead exemption means is that the debtor can have up to $50,000 of equity in the residence ($100,000 for a married couple) and your home will not be taken or threatened by the bankruptcy trustee or other creditors. If there are judgments against the debtor, they are viewed as impairing debtor’s exemption in the property and gives the debtor the right to remove them.

If you do not own a residence when you file your bankruptcy, you do not need to set aside the judgment in the County Clerk’s office, but the underlying debts are discharged regardless whether the judgment is removed. This may become a a problem if you purchase (or inherit) real property after your bankruptcy. In that situation, even though there is no actual lien against the newly acquired property, it may appear that there is to someone searching the Clerk’s office. This is because they will see a judgment against you, and they will see that you own the property. Without knowing about the intervening bankruptcy and the discharge of the debt that underlies the judgment, they could draw the conclusion that the judgment was in fact a lien against the property.

The problem often surfaces if there comes a time that you want to borrow against, or refinance the property. Most lenders are sophisticated enough to recognize that any pre-bankruptcy judgments are usually discharged and a typical judgment search, or a title search, in Monroe County will include a check of the Bankruptcy Court’s records. It is also the reason to keep a copy of your discharge after the bankruptcy so that the lender can have easy verification that the bankruptcy resulted in a discharge.

If you are dealing with debt problems in Rochester, New York; Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation with a bankruptcy attorney.

Chapter 13 and Payment of Student Loans Under the Plan

Unless the bankruptcy debtor can satisfy the daunting legal standard of “undue hardship,” student loans are not dischargeable in a bankruptcy case. However, the mere fact that student loans will not be discharged does not mean you should give up on the bankruptcy process. For a chapter 13 debtor, the question might be, how should the chapter 13 payment plan propose to treat the student loan debt?

Some attorneys try to distribute more of the debtor’s income to student loan debts than to other debts by simply inserting a provision into the chapter 13 plan which says that the debtor will continue to pay the student loan out of his or her own pocket, rather than have the chapter 13 trustee pay toward the student loan. This would have the important advantage of paying more (usually) toward the student loan than would be paid if the trustee made the payments from the plan.

The presumptive authority for paying a student loan “outside the plan” is contained in the bankruptcy law’s section 1322(b)(5). This section permits the maintaining of payments on any debt where the last regularly scheduled payment is due after the final chapter 13 plan payment is due. Section 1322(b) reads as follows:

(b) Subject to subsections (a) and (c) of this section, the plan may–

designate a class or classes of unsecured claims, as provided in section 1121 of this title, but may not discriminate unfairly against any class so designated; however, such plan may treat claims for a consumer debt of the debtor if an individual is liable on such consumer debt with the debtor differently than other unsecured claims;
modify the rights of holders of secured claims, other than a claim secured only by a security interest in real property that is the debtor’s principal residence, or of holders of unsecured claims, or leave unaffected the rights of holders of any class of claims;
provide for the curing or waiving of any default;
provide for payments on any unsecured claim to be made concurrently with payments on any secured claim or any other unsecured claim;
notwithstanding paragraph (2) of this subsection, provide for the curing of any default within a reasonable time and maintenance of payments while the case is pending on any unsecured claim or secured claim on which the last payment is due after the date on which the final payment under the plan is due;

Section 1322(b) allows the chapter 13 debtor to continue making student loan payments directly to the creditor, much the same as the debtor would continue paying his mortgage payments, assuming that the bankruptcy trustee agrees with this interpretation and the bankruptcy court confirms it. However, here in Rochester, the Chapter 13 trustee disagrees with this interpretation of the statute and, instead, takes a position that the student loans should be paid pro-rata as other unsecured creditors. The trustee’s position is based on the argument that making full student loan payments, while in Chapter 13, treats student loan lenders better than other unsecured creditors and, in fact, does so at their expense. While Judge Ninfo has not written on this issue, I think that he would agree with the trustee’s position. Thus, it is critical to discuss these issues with a bankruptcy lawyer prior to the filing.

Bankruptcy Basics – Preferences

The Bankruptcy Code permits a trustee to recover from creditors payments made shortly before the bankruptcy filing, where the payment gave the creditor more than other creditors in a similar position would get through the bankruptcy process.

The policy behind the statute is to reduce the advantages that a creditor might get by suing or by collection activities that force the debtor into bankruptcy. That is accomplished by making payments received in the 90 days before the filing recoverable in bankruptcy by the trustee.

It is neither wrong for the debtor to make a preferential payment, nor is it wrong for a creditor to accept such payment. The preference statutes are simply an attempt to achieve equity between creditors.

Bankruptcy Code §547 defines a preference as:

Payment on an antecedent (as opposed to current) debt;
Made while the debtor was insolvent;
To a non-insider creditor, within 90 days of the filing of the bankruptcy;
That allows the creditor to receive more on its claim than it would have, had the payment not been made and the claim paid through the bankruptcy proceeding.

Any payments to a fully secured creditor are not usually preferences, because the creditor would not get more than he would have in bankruptcy, where the creditor would get the value of the collateral.

While the look back period for preferences is usually 90 days, the bankruptcy code also permits the recovery of payments on claims owed to insiders, such as relatives, friends, corporate officers or directors, or related entities, made within 1 year of the bankruptcy filing. This provision attempts to prevent the debtor from paying relatives, friends and business decision makers at the expense of other creditors.

Preference recovery is generally a matter between the trustee and a creditor. When the creditor is a third party, the debtor may not care very much. When the creditor in question is a relative or a friend, however, most debtors are very concerned. If a bankruptcy case is filed within a year of these payments to relatives and friends, the trustee may take the money from the friend or relative the debtor paid, and redistribute it to creditors in accordance with the bankruptcy laws.

There are some procedural issues that apply to preferences. For example, a payment made by check is effective as of the date the check cleared, not the date on the check or the date it was mailed. There are also some defenses to preferences, usually available in a business rather than a consumer setting. Preferences can be voluntary payments, like a check sent in payment of an invoice, or involuntary, like attaching a bank account.

A debtor needs someone with knowledge and experience in these issue on his side. One of the most valuable things an experienced bankruptcy attorney can do is prevent problems for you, and unintended consequences for your family members or business partners. It is also best to seek such advice before you make that payment, or transfer that asset. Lawyers can control damage in most situations, but we prefer to prevent a problem arising in the first place and this can be accomplished in most situation with pre-bankruptcy planning.

Bankruptcy Basics – Credit Counseling and Financial Education Requirements

Under the BAPCPA, debtors planning to file for bankruptcy, under either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13, must complete a consumer credit counseling course before they will be allowed to file a bankruptcy petition. Such credit counseling program needs to be completed within 180 days prior to the filing.

A pre-bankruptcy counseling session with an approved credit counseling organization usually includes an evaluation of the debtor’s personal financial situation, a discussion of alternatives to bankruptcy, and a personal budget plan. A typical counseling course lasts about 60 to 90 minutes, and can take place in person, on the phone, or on internet. The counseling organization is required to provide the counseling free of charge for those consumers who cannot afford to pay. If you cannot afford to pay a fee for credit counseling, you should request a fee waiver from the counseling organization before the session begins. Otherwise, you may be charged a fee for the counseling, which will generally be about $50, depending on where you live, the types of services you receive, and other factors. The counseling organization is required to discuss any fees with you before starting the counseling session.

Once you have completed the required counseling, you must get a certificate as proof. You can check if the organization providing the course is approved in the judicial district where you are filing bankruptcy by going to the U.S Trustee’s web site. Once the course is completed, you will receive the certificate. Credit counseling organizations may not charge an extra fee for the certificate.

In addition, once the bankruptcy is filed, debtor must obtain debt management counseling before being allowed to complete the bankruptcy process. A debtor education course by an approved provider usually includes information on developing a budget, managing money, using credit wisely, and other resources. Like pre-filing counseling, debtor education may be provided in person, on the phone, or online. The debtor education session might last longer than the pre-filing counseling – about two hours – and the typical fee is between $50 and $100. As with pre-filing counseling, if you are unable to pay the session fee, you should seek a fee waiver from the debtor education provider. Make sure that you received the certificate from a debtor education provider that is approved in the judicial district where you filed bankruptcy. Check the list of approved debtor education providers at the U.S. Trustee’s web site.

There are three main objectives of the Personal Financial Management course:

The help the debtor understand the benefits of creating short-term and long-term financial goals.
To teach the debtor how to create a budget.
To teach the debtor how to balance a checkbook and reconcile bank statements.

The purpose of these courses is to help the debtor become financially literate and avoid another bankruptcy.

Once you have completed the required debtor education course, you should receive a certificate as proof. This certificate is a different document from the certificate you received after completing your pre-filing credit counseling. Unless they have disclosed a charge to you before the counseling session begins, debtor education providers may not charge an extra fee for the certificate.

The Personal Financial Management course must be completed within 45 days after filing bankruptcy; but before receiving a discharge through bankruptcy. This is important because if the debtor does not complete this second course after filing for bankruptcy, the Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy may be closed without a discharge.

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy and Objections to Discharge

You have filed a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. You and your lawyer went to the meeting of the creditors. Everything seemed to be in order. Then your lawyer calls you, and tells you that one of your creditors has filed an adversary proceeding in your Chapter 7 case, objecting to discharge of its debt. So what exactly is taking place?

If a creditor determines that an objection with respect to discharge of its debt is warranted, the creditor will file an Objection to Discharge of its particular debt. This filing begins what is known as an adversarial proceeding in the bankruptcy court. An adversarial proceeding is simply a law suit within the bankruptcy, seeking to declare a particular debt as non-dischargeable. The debtor responds to the complaint, evidence is gathered and supplied to both sides, and a hearing is held in front of the bankruptcy judge who decides the case. Here in Rochester, Hon. John C. Ninfo, II, would hear the case. Typically, neither the bankruptcy trustee nor the U.S. Trustee are involved in the adversarial proceeding.

A creditor may object to the discharge of its debt in a number of different situations. An unsecured creditor may object using Section 523(a)(2) of the Bankruptcy Code, which contains several different types of non-dischargeable debt. The debt under that section may not be dischargeable because it is: (1) $500 owing to a single creditor for the purchase of “luxury” goods within 90 days prior to filing of the bankruptcy; (2) $750 owing to a single creditor for a cash advance (i.e. balance transfers are cash advances) obtained within 70 days prior to filing of the bankruptcy; or (3) for money obtained under false pretenses, false representation, or actual fraud. There are also additional reasons to declare a debt non-dischargeable.

With respect to situations (1) and (2), the applicable rules are known as as the per-se rules. That means that the creditor need not prove debtor’s intent (i.e. fraud), and needs to show only that the transactions meet the criteria stated. Situation (3) means that the debtor made the charges/cash advances knowing that he/she was going to file bankruptcy, or made the charges/cash advances while insolvent and/or could not have had a reasonable expectation to pay back the debt, or made false representations in obtaining credit resulting in the debt he/she is trying to discharge at this time.

If the creditor is successful in having a debt declared non-dischargeable, the debtor will owe that debt until it is paid, with all accumulating interest, and the debtor can never discharge that debt.

The following is a brief description of procedural issues applicable to the objections. The complaint must be filed on or before 60 days from the first date set for the creditors meeting (also know as 341 meeting). Typically, a creditor has less than 90 days after receiving notice of the bankruptcy case to file a complaint. A creditor must act promptly to determine there are grounds to object to discharge.

Even if a creditor files an objection to discharge of its debt, the rest of the bankruptcy will proceed normally. The debtor will recieve the discharge on time, and most of the time, the discharge will be received before the hearing in the adversarial proceeding.

Once the adversarial proceeding is filed, the debtor has a number of options with respect to the creditor’s claim. The debtor can agree to repay all or a portion of the debt by signing a reaffirmation agreement. A typical reaffirmation agreement results in the debtor paying 50% of the debt over 12-18 months. The next option is fighting the objection. The debtor will have to be able to either fight the objection on his/her own or pay an additional retainer to the attorney to fight the claim.

The way that a creditor proves its case, is by showing to the court that the debtor was in financial distress at the time the objectionable transactions were made. Therefore, the debtor’s financial history will be disclosed through the discovery process, usually for a period of 12 months prior to the challenged transaction, and from the date of the transaction to the date of filing. Since an adversarial proceeding is a civil matter, both parties may call witnesses, and the debtor may be called to testify by either side. A creditor’s theory of the case in an adversarial proceeding is usually that no reasonable person could have expected to be able to pay off the debt, at the time that debt was taken out.

If the creditor wins, a judgment is entered, declaring the debt non-dischargable. This judgment can ultimately be used in New York State court, or elsewhere, to obtain a money judgment that can then be used to garnish wages, restrain bank accounts or conduct other collection activities. That judgment will not be dischargeable in any subsequent bankrupcies and can only be extinguished by payment or by New York’s statute of limitations, presently 20 years. Even if the creditor prevails, the debtor is not responsible for the creditor’s attorney’s fees and costs.

If the debtor wins, the debt is discharged, and, under appropriate circumstances, the creditor will have to pay debtor’s attorney’s fees and costs.

Thus, if an adversarial proceeding is brought, the debtor must choose between either settling or fighting. The cost to defend an adversarial proceding is usually substantial. Therefore, it should be compared to the cost of settling the case. If the proposed settlement reduces the debt and the payments are affordable, especially if the settlement amount is less than the cost to defend, the debtor should consider settlement.

If you are dealing with debt problems in Rochester, New York, Canandaigua, Brighton, Pittsford, Penfield, Perinton, Fairport, Webster, Victor, Farmington, Greece, Gates, Hilton, Parma, Brockport, Spencerport, LeRoy, Chili, Churchville, Monroe County, Ontario County, Wayne County, Orleans County, Livingston County, and being harassed by bill collectors, and would like to know more about how bankruptcy may be able to help you, contact me today by phone or email to schedule a FREE initial consultation.

Bankruptcy Basics – Meeting of the Creditors

The creditors’ meeting, otherwise known as 341 meeting, is a procedural step in every Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy. In a typical 341 meeting, the debtor will be asked questions under oath by the bankruptcy trustee with respect to his or her financial affairs. Most debtors are apprehensive of the 341 meeting. While 341 meeting is also designated as the first meeting of the creditors, creditors seldom come to the first meeting, and there isn’t usually a second meeting. Most of the time, it is a meeting of the debtor and the trustee appointed in the case.

There are two items that the debtor must have at the 341 creditor’s meeting. The first one is a state issued photo identification card. For most people, this is going to be their driver’s license. The second item is the social security card. If the debtor does not have these documents at the meeting, the trustee cannot go forward with the creditors’ meeting since the trustee must confirm the debtor’s identity. Occasionally, trustee may permit the use of a W2 forms, annual social security statements, or a payroll check stub that contains debtor’s social security number.

Take the time to locate these documents before you arrive at the location for your creditor’s meeting. Here in Rochester, bankruptcy trustees usually tell the debtors to have their identification and proof of social security number ready at the beginning of the meeting. Most bankruptcy attorneys will ask the clients for those documents so they can be handed t the trustee. I often have seen people anxiously looking through a purse or wallet for a social security card that they just know they have, only to find out that they don’t have it, or that they are too nervous to find.

The 341 meeting is not a test or a trial. The trustee won’t be asking any trick questions. Your lawyer is there for support and to make sure that the record created is truthful and accurate. In order to have a successful 341 meeting all the debtor has to do is to follow these four steps: (1) tell the truth; (2) listen to the question; (3) let the trustee finish before you start speaking; and (4) answer in as few words as possible.

It is critical for someone who filed bankruptcy to be honest during 341 hearing. It is just as critical for the debtor to be honest with his/her attorney prior to the hearing, before the petition is prepared out and filed. If the debtor’s statements during the 341 hearing contradict the petition, and those contradictions were deliberate on the part of the debtor, that means the debtor may have already committed perjury, which is a federal offense. When the petition is filed, the debtor, by signing his or her petition, swore that the petition was truthful.

There are a number of questions that a trustee is required to ask the debtor at the meeting of creditors. They are as follows:

1. State your name and current address for the record.

2. Please provide your picture ID and Social Security number card for review.

3. Did you sign the petition, schedules, statements, and related documents and is the signature your own? Did you read the petition, schedules, statements, and related documents before you signed them?

4. Are you personally familiar with the information contained in the petition, schedules, statements and related documents? To the best of your knowledge, is the information contained in the petition, schedules, statements, and related documents true and correct? Are there any errors or omissions to bring to my attention at this time?

5. Are all of your assets identified on the schedules? Have you listed all of your creditors on the schedules?

6. Have you previously filed bankruptcy? (provide trustee with case number and the discharge information to determine discharge eligibility in this case)

7. What is the address of your current employer?

8. Is the copy of the tax return you provided a true copy of the most recent tax return you filed?

9. Do you have a domestic support obligation? To whom? Please provide the claimant’s address and telephone number, but do not state it on the record. Are you current on your post-petition domestic support obligations?

10. Have you filed all required tax returns for the past four years?

There are also other questions that a trustee may ask you:

1. Do you own or have any interest whatsoever in any real estate? If owned: When did you purchase the property? How much did the property cost? What are the mortgages encumbering it? How did you arrive at the value of the property?

2. Have you made any transfers of any property or given any property away within the last one year period?

3. Does anyone hold property belonging to you? If yes: Who holds the property and what is it? What is its value?

4. Do you have a claim against anyone or any business? If there are large medical debts, are the medical bills from injury? Are you the plaintiff in any lawsuit? What is the status of each case and who is representing you?

5. Are you entitled to life insurance proceeds or an inheritance as a result of someone’s death? If you become a beneficiary of any one’s estate within six months of the date your bankruptcy petition was filed, the trustee must be advised within ten days through your counsel of the nature and extent of the property you will receive.

6. Does anyone owe you money? Who owes the money and where are they?

7. Have you made any large payments, over $600, to anyone in the past year?

8. Were federal income tax returns filed on a timely basis? When was the last return filed? Do you have copies of the federal income tax returns? At the time of the filing of your petition, were you entitled to a tax refund from the federal or state government ?

9. Do you have a bank account, either checking or savings? If yes: In what banks and what were the balances as of the date you filed your petition?

10. When you filed your petition, did you have:

a. any cash on hand?
b. any U.S. savings bonds?
c. any other stocks or bonds?
d. any certificates of deposit?
e. a safe deposit box in your name or in anyone else’s name?

11. Do you own an automobile? If yes: What is the year, make, and value? Do you owe any money on it? Is it insured?

12. Are you the owner of any cash value life insurance policies? If yes: State the name of the company, face amount of the policy, cash surrender value, if any, and the beneficiaries.

13. Do you anticipate that you might realize any property, cash or otherwise, as a result of a divorce or separation proceeding?

14. Have you been engaged in any business during the last six years? If yes: Where and when? What happened to the assets of the business?

As log as you and your bankruptcy lawyer are prepared, your 341 hearing is likely to be completed quickly. If you are missing documents or if trustee requires additional information, your hearing may be rescheduled to a later date.

Bankruptcy Basics – Domestic Support Obligations

On occasion, a divorce may result in one or both of the parties filing for bankruptcy, often without an adequate understanding of the limited relief available in the bankruptcy court. The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (”BAPCPA”) directly addressed issues related to the dischargeability of marital debt and support obligations, as well as to the effect of the automatic stay on collection and enforcement proceedings out of divorce and family law litigation. Under BAPCPA, domestic support obligations (usually alimony, child support and property distribution) are given priority over almost every other creditor.

Under bankruptcy law, a “domestic support obligation” is any debt incurred before or after a bankruptcy filing that is owed to or recoverable by a spouse, former spouse, child or governmental unit; in the nature of alimony, maintenance or support; and established pursuant to the terms of a divorce decree, separation agreement, property settlement agreement, court order or administrative determination.

In Chapter 7 bankruptcy, essentially all marital and domestic relations obligations are not dischargeable, regardless of whether they are support in nature, property divisions or “hold harmless” agreements, provided they were incurred by the debtor in the course of a matrimonial proceeding or a divorce action which resulted in a separation agreement, divorce decree, court order or administrative determination.

A debtor’s obligation to pay marital debts directly to a third party ( ie., pay the mortgage on former marital residence) and to hold the former spouse harmless on said debts is also deemed to be non-dischargeable if the obligation has the effect of providing support to the former spouse. A debtor’s duty to pay the following expenses are usually deemed to be in the nature of support and not dischargeable: educational expenses of a minor child; medical insurance coverage for a minor child; and life insurance, with the minor children as beneficiaries.

Attorney’s fees owed by debtor to his own lawyer are clearly dischargeable in bankruptcy, but as a general rule, attorney’s fees owed by debtor to a former spouse’s attorney are not dischargeable, if the underlying legal proceeding resulted in the entry of an order or judgment directing payment of maintenance or spousal support to the former spouse.

The division of a debtor’s pension benefits during the divorce action is usually accomplished by entering a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (”QDRO”). Since division of a pension is considered to be a transfer by debtor of a present interest in his pension, and as such, it is not a debt that can be discharged in bankruptcy.

If there are assets in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, and you owe any domestic support obligations (alimony, child support, that sort of thing) to your spouse, former spouse or child, the trustee will pay that first. Next, the trustee will pay any domestic support obligation owed to a governmental unit.

In Chapter 13 bankruptcy, past due domestic support obligations owed by a debtor are not dischargeable, unless they are paid in full over the life of the Chapter 13 plan. However, if a debt created by a separation agreement or judgment of divorce is not in the nature of support, it sometimes can be discharged in Chapter 13 without being paid in full.

For a Chapter 13 Plan to be confirmed by the Bankruptcy Court, it must: pay in full to the former spouse all domestic support obligations owed by debtor at the time of the bankruptcy filing, and the debtor must be current on all domestic support obligations incurred after the bankruptcy filing. Past due support obligations are generally required to be paid in full through the debtor’s plan but an exception can be made if the creditor agrees. Support debts have a first priority, meaning they are paid before other kinds of priority debts, like taxes.

A Chapter 13 Plan, even if confirmed by the bankruptcy court, is subject to dismissal if the debtor fails to pay any post-petition or post-confirmation domestic support obligations, and a Chapter 13 discharge will not be entered by the bankruptcy court unless and until a debtor certifies that all domestic support obligations have been paid and that the debtor is current on such obligations.

The automatic stay created by a bankruptcy filing bars the commencement or continuation of most legal proceedings, but it has no effect on a proceeding to establish paternity; to establish or modify a child support order, determine child custody or visitation issues, or dissolve a marriage, except to the extent that such proceeding may seek to determine a division of marital property in which the bankruptcy estate also has an interest. In those situations, the divorce can be granted without first obtaining relief from the automatic stay, but the marital property cannot be divided without obtaining such relief.

The automatic stay also does not prevent the post-petition collection of domestic support obligations such as alimony or child support from any property belonging to the debtor, providing that the bankruptcy estate does not also have an interest in the same property; from automatic wage deduction orders created by a statute or judicial or administrative order; from the interception of debtor’s federal or state income tax refunds, or
from the withholding, suspension or restriction of a debtor’s driver’s license or professional or occupational license. Therefore, Bankruptcy Court does not offer much protection for someone seeking to avoid the domestic support obligations.

The above rules will apply to the proceedings in New York State courts. In Ross v. Sperow, 57 A.D.3d 1255 (3rd Dept. 2008), the Appellate Division had to address a situation where one of the parties was seeking to enforce a counsel fee award after the other party filed for bankruptcy. In Ross, multiple violation petitions had been filed by the parties over the course of several years. In August 2006, Family Court upheld mother’s motion for attorneys fees and directed father to pay $5,000 of the mother’s attorneys fees. Father filed for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy thereafter, and listed the award of attorneys fees as an unsecured debt. Father’s bankruptcy was discharged in January 2007. Mother brought a violation petition which alleged that father failed to pay the attorneys fees. Father moved to dismiss petition on ground that he discharged counsel fee award in bankruptcy. The Appellate Division stated that state and federal courts have concurrent jurisdiction over issue of dischargabilityof a particular debt and held that domestic support obligations in the nature of support are exempt from discharge in bankruptcy. While father contended that counsel fees incurred were for custody and visitation proceeding, the record reveals that mother’s initial petition commencing the proceeding raised issues of financial need and hardship. According to the Appellate Division, term “in the nature of support” is broadly interpreted in the context of discharge of debt obligations in bankruptcy and held that the award of counsel fees was in part in the nature of support, and as such, exempt from discharge in bankruptcy.

It is very important for your bankruptcy lawyer to be aware of any outstanding domestic support obligations if you are filing for bankruptcy. Here in Rochester, bankruptcy trustees routinely ask during the meeting of creditors (also known as 341 meeting), if the debtor has a domestic support obligation. If there is a domestic support obligation, the bankruptcy trustee will want to know to whom such obligation is payable, will ask the debtor to provide the claimant’s address and telephone number, and will inquire if the debtor is current on his or her post-petition domestic support obligations.